HAWTS vs VAWTs: Selecting wind turbines for urban sites
N. Mughees | September 18, 2023Industries, even those in urban locations, are beginning to see wind power as a viable alternative because of the increasing need for clean and sustainable energy. Electricity generated by wind turbines is both sustainable and dependable. The decision to deploy horizontal axis wind turbines (HAWTs) or vertical axis wind turbines (VAWTs), both of which are used in industrial settings, becomes more important when considering urban placement.
HAWTs in urban industries
When converting wind energy into three-phase AC electricity, HAWTs are a common choice. They are distinguished by their horizontal rotor shaft and tower installation. Two or three aerodynamically constructed rotor blades are coupled to a hub in a HAWT, and the entire assembly is set in motion by a horizontal axis that is perpendicular to the direction of the wind.
These turbines have been in use for some time at utility-scale wind farms and also offer certain distinct benefits for industrial purposes in urban settings:
- Power generation and scalability: HAWTs may be found in a range of sizes, making them flexible enough to meet a wide range of applications in industry. They can be expanded to produce more power, making them ideal for use in factories and other energy-hungry establishments.
- Effectiveness in producing energy: HAWTs are well-known for their superiority over VAWTs in terms of harvesting wind energy. Powering urban businesses, HAWTs may generate massive quantities of electricity in places with enough wind resources and open spaces.
- Proven methodologies: HAWTs are an established technology after decades of research, development and deployment in wind energy projects. As the technology has been around for a while, they tend to operate well, require less upkeep and have plenty of replacement parts accessible.
VAWTs in urban industries
VAWTs are an alternative to traditional HAWTs, differing in operation and design. VAWTs are distinguished by their vertical rotor shaft and vertical blade arrangement. Since the rotor blades are vertically oriented, there is no need to align the turbine with the wind's direction in order to harvest its power. Particular benefits of VAWTs make them well suited for use in urban industrial settings:
- Omni-directional wind capture: The buildings and structures in an urban environment create intricate wind patterns. Because they are able to harness wind from any direction, VAWTs thrive in these conditions. They are less sensitive to changes in wind direction, making them suitable for use in urban areas.
- Space efficiency: Space is at a premium in most urban settings. Since VAWTs are vertically oriented, they may be set up even in confined spaces like rooftops, parking lots and on the sides of buildings. VAWTs are more practical for urban industry seeking to collect wind energy without substantial land requirements due to their smaller size.
- Effectiveness at low wind velocities: The average wind speed is often lower in urban regions than in rural ones. VAWTs are optimized for use in areas with low wind speeds, making them a good fit for urban industry in places where access to wind power is limited. They are able to harvest wind energy despite the presence of wind turbulence generated by buildings in metropolitan settings.
- Issues of appearance and noise: Many people find VAWTs appealing aesthetically, and they may be seamlessly incorporated into the urban landscape. VAWTs are more socially acceptable in noise-sensitive metropolitan settings because they rotate at lower rates, resulting in lower noise levels.
[Discover more about HAWT and VAWT technology and suppliers on GlobalSpec]
Critical factors for urban industrial uses
- Access to open spaces: There is often not a lot of room for wind turbine farms in densely populated urban areas. To assess if HAWTs or VAWTs can be properly housed, planners must evaluate the available space, which may include roofs, parking lots or open spaces.
- Evaluation of wind resources: It is critical to do a comprehensive evaluation of the wind resource in the target urban area. When deciding between HAWTs and VAWTs, planners must weigh environmental factors including average wind speed, turbulence and changes in wind direction.
- Power requirements: Selecting the correct wind turbine requires a thorough comprehension of the industrial facility's energy requirements. Distributed power generation with VAWTs is an option for industries with lower power needs, whereas larger-scale HAWTs may be necessary for industries with higher power needs.
- Maintenance needs: Accessibility for periodic maintenance and any necessary repairs is an important factor to think about. When compared to VAWTs, HAWTs tend to be more difficult to maintain and service in metropolitan areas due to their larger size and more involved operations.
- Compliance with local laws and zoning ordinances: Before siting setting up wind turbines, zoning laws and other local regulations should be analyzed in order to secure the appropriate licenses. In some cases, the type of wind turbine that may be installed is limited by zoning laws.
[Learn about the latest wind energy developments with a free subscription to the Alternative & Renewable Energy newsletter from GlobalSpec]
Conclusion
HAWTs and VAWTs each have their own set of benefits when it comes to urban industrial applications. HAWTs are suited for major industrial operations because to their high efficiency and scalability. VAWTs, on the other hand, can capture wind energy from any direction and work effectively even at low wind speeds, making them ideal for urban settings with little space. Factors including wind resource availability, space limits, power needs and aesthetic concerns should be taken into account while deciding between HAWTs and VAWTs for urban industry.