Cold Ironing: The Drive to Make Commercial Shipping CleanerMorand Fachot, communications officer, International Electrotechnical Commission | October 22, 2015
Ships are like floating cities; they produce and distribute their own electricity. When docked and not sailing, they mainly use auxiliary units that predominantly burn fuel oil to provide the necessary power.
Increasingly, ports are installing onshore power supplies (OPS) to deliver electric power to berthed ships to meet tighter air emission limits. This is being helped by the development of International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) international standards for high-voltage and low-voltage (HV / LV) OPS systems.
Out of Sight, Still in the Lungs
Unlike airliners or motor vehicles, shipping is not seen by most people. Levels of pollution from the maritime industry have long been underestimated.
Most main and auxiliary marine engines burn bunker fuel. This petroleum product was once described by Christian Eyde Moller, CEO of the Netherlands-based DK shipping company, as “just waste oil, basically what is left over after all the cleaner fuels have been extracted from crude oil. It’s tar, the same as asphalt. It’s the cheapest and dirtiest fuel in the world.”
Bunker fuel has high sulphur content and its combustion results in excessive levels of sulphur oxide (SOx), nitrogen oxide (NOx) and PM (particulate matter); the last pollutant is particularly harmful.
A 2009 study from the University of Delaware in the U.S. blamed ship emissions for 64,000 deaths a year worldwide, of which some 27,000 were in Europe.
The International Maritime Organization (IMO), the United Nations agency with responsibility for the safety and security of shipping and the prevention of marine pollution by ships, has introduced international limits that specify the maximum sulphur content in bunker fuel as part of Annex VI of its International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships (MARPOL).
This fixes limits on SOx and NOx emissions from ship exhausts. The maximum sulphur content of bunker fuel was set at 3.5% from Jan. 1, 2012 until January 2020, with lower levels to be introduced later. Ships can meet the new requirements by using low sulphur fuel oil such as marine gas oil (MGO, sometimes called distillates), or gas.
Some regions (including the Baltic, North Sea, North America and Caribbean Sea areas) have introduced tighter limits in so-called Emission Control Areas (ECAs). Ships trading in these areas have to use fuel oil with a sulphur content of no more than 0.1% as of Jan. 1, 2015.
Widespread consensus exists on finding ways to achieve cleaner international shipping. Even if auxiliary generators used to provide electric power to docked ships burn cleaner fuels rather than bunker fuel, they still emit CO2, SOx, NOx and PM. During a 10-hour stay in port, for example, the diesel engines of a single cruise ship burn around 20 tonnes of fuel, producing some 60 tonnes of CO2.
On average, ships spend 100 days a year in port and consume several tonnes of fuel each day to power ancillary systems. Ports are often located in densely populated cities and the environmental impact on the local population may be severe.
Providing electric power from shore to ships at berth to cut noxious emissions produced by ships’ generators is not a recent development; in fact the term commonly used to describe it—“cold ironing”—dates back to a time when ships had coal-fired boilers that were allowed to go completely cold when in port, as power was supplied from shore.
Navy ships, which on average stay in port much longer than commercial ships, make extensive use of cold ironing. The U.S. Navy, for instance, has been using it for several decades and has developed a unique electrical cable connection system to avoid compatibility issues when calling at different ports.
Generally speaking, first-generation onshore power supply systems operate on low voltages (400-690 V). More recently, high voltage (6-11 kV) has become the standard.
Currently, dozens of ports in North America and Europe implement high voltage shore connection (HVSC), but systems across the world are not interoperable, owing to the lack of standardization and differences in system frequency (60 Hz in North America, 50 Hz in Europe and most of Asia), voltage and structural design.
Voltage levels differ between ports and electrical frequencies and power requirements also vary among vessel categories and sizes. Ocean-going vessels calling at European ports tend to have more 60 Hz electrical systems on board. Peak power demand varies from 1 megawatt (MW) for container vessels smaller than 140 meters in length to more than 10 MW for cruise ships greater than 200 meters in length.
These different systems and the specific local situation determine whether or not frequency converters and/or on-board transformers are needed, and may affect the overall cost of an OPS system for port authorities and ship owners.
To meet these needs, a number of IEC Technical committees and subcommittees started developing international standards for HVSC systems.
In 2009, IEC TC 18: Electrical installations of ships and of mobile and fixed offshore units, issued a publicly available specification (PAS) giving requirements for HVSC systems. The PAS stated that "HVSC systems will have practicable applications for ships requiring 1 MW or more or ships with HV main supply."
A PAS is a technical specification, a pre-standard publication that does not fulfil the requirements for a standard, but is made available to the public and can be transformed into an international standard by the relevant committee and subcommittees.
This PAS was prepared by IEC TC 18 in consultation with IEC TC 20: Electric cables and IEC SC 18A. It was further developed into an international standard in cooperation with IEC subcommittee 23H: Industrial plugs and socket-outlets, ISO TC 8: Ships and marine technology, and the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) Petroleum and Chemical Industry Committee (PCIC).
Indeed, this standard, IEC/ISO/IEEE 80005-1, “Utility connections in port – Part 1: High Voltage Shore Connection (HVSC) Systems – General requirements,” was published in July 2012. It describes HVSC systems on board ships and on shore and defines "requirements that support, with the application of suitable operating practices, efficiency and safety of connections by compliant ships to compliant high-voltage shore power supplies through a compatible shore to ship connection."
The standard is intended to allow different ships "to connect to HVSC at different berths with the benefits of standard, straightforward connection without the need for adaptation and adjustment at different locations that can satisfy the requirement to connect for as long as practicable during stays in port.” Ships that do not apply this standard may find it difficult or impossible to connect to compliant shore supplies.
To meet these demands IEC/ISO/IEEE 80005-1 addresses:
- HV shore distribution systems
- Shore-to-ship connection and interface equipment
- Semiconductor/rotating convertors
- Ship distribution systems
- Control, monitoring, interlocking and power management systems.
The standard tackles important safety aspects such as emergency shutdowns when the ship moves outside the range of permissible motion forward, after or outward from the dock, and special provisions that are applicable to emergency shutdowns at liquefied natural gas terminals.
The standard also lists additional requirements for RoRo (roll-on/roll-off) cargo and passenger ships, cruise and container ships, tankers and LNG carriers.
The relevant IEC, ISO and IEEE committees are currently working on developing a second international standard for HSVC, to cover the communication interface.
Low Voltage in the Power Loop
In addition to HVSC, the need to develop international standards for low voltage shore connection (LVSC) with "practicable applications for ships requiring up to 1 MVA," emerged. To meet this need, TC 18 published, IEC PAS 80005-3:2014, “Utility connections in port – Part 3: Low Voltage Shore Connection (LVSC) Systems - General requirements.”
Like IEC/ISO/IEEE 80005-1, this PAS was prepared by IEC TC 18 in consultation with IEC TC 20 and IEC SC 18A and in cooperation with the same technical committees and subcommittees from the IEC and other organizations (ISO and IEEE). It will be further developed into an international standard. It addresses the same features as IEC/ISO/IEEE 80005-1 (with the exception of LV shore distribution systems, which replace HV shore distribution systems).
International standards prepared by the same and other IEC technical committees and subcommittees, are "normatively referenced in" and "indispensable for" the application of both IEC/ISO/IEEE 80005-1 and IEC PAS 80005-3.
From an environmental perspective, the use of both HSVC and LVSC is compelling.
Compared to low-sulphur (0.1%) marine gas oil used in EU ports (2010 limit), OPS cuts NOx, PM and volatile organic compound emissions by 97%, 89% and 94%, respectively, according to the 2005 “Shore-Side Electricity” report from Entec UK Ltd for the European Commission.